Thanks! Really!


1903 - 1912 Rosthern's first Mennonite sanctuary; 1913 - 2014 Rosthern New Church Society, 2016- present. Chapel preserved by Mennonite Interpretive Centre on the Rosthern Junior College campus.
© Thanks! Really!
Thanksgiving Sunday, October 13th, 2019
Aberdeen Mennonite Church

If you’re like me, you probably have a set of associations relating to Thanksgiving Day. Turkey, cranberry sauce, pumpkin pie come to mind easily. Autumn leaves, the picture of bins brimming with wheat, crisp cold of October mornings, and displays of grain sheaves, garden produce and fruit in an amazing still-life at the front of church. And the hymns, “We plow the fields and scatter, the good seed on the land, but it is fed and watered by God’s almighty hand.” And maybe some of us think first of “Come, ye thankful people come, raise the song of harvest home. All is safely gathered in, ere the winter storms begin.”

The association of harvest and Thanksgiving is probably as old as the time when wandering, nomadic cultures began to cultivate crops, domesticate animals for food.

For most Christians, grace at meals constitutes a mini-Thanksgiving repeated thrice daily. It’s a reminder that our very survival depends on the security of our food supply, something that can’t always be guaranteed on an earth subject to drought, flood, hail, fire or hurricane.

I’m sure the people most thankful after a successful harvest are those living in the most marginal food-producing areas, where food must be scavenged and malnutrition hovers overhead always like a dark, threatening cloud.

It’s probably we in the West and North of the world who most need to remind ourselves that the sustaining, caring hand of God has for so long been associated with food or no food. What does it mean in an age where the food supply for some has been so certain that people are likely to pray for an effective ,weight-reducing diet at the same time as others are praying for a piece of bread, a morsel of mango, anything to postpone the agony of starvation, if just for another day.

In the 1929-1933 period of Stalin’s collectivization, food grains were confiscated from collective farms to feed Moscow and to boost the Russian economy generally. It was a ruthless regime that pitilessly left whole villages to starve. News came to Canada via the few pleading letters for help that managed to evade censorship, and North American Mennonites responded with food enough to save at least some of their brothers and sisters.

The stories include heart-wrenching accounts of making soup with poplar leaves, of families being evicted because they were found to have withheld a small bag of flour from the government.

“Segne Vater diese Speise; uns zur Kraft, und dir zum Preise.” The table graces of my childhood have never left me: “Lord bless this food so that it will nourish us well, while honouring your name.” Or “Komm, Herr Jesu, sei du unser Gast, Und segne was du uns aus Gnaden bescheret hast, Amen.”(Come Lord Jesus be our guest, and bless what your grace has provided for us.) We sing “Praise God from whom all blessings flow . . .” before sitting down to potluck in church and though the words may slide too easily off our tongues sometimes because our minds are already in the potato salad bowl, we sing it because we know how enormous a blessing soil and rain and sunshine, a chicken in the oven and peas from the garden actually are.

Is it even possible to be adequately thankful to God for such amazing blessings?

Before I began writing this sermon, I thought about the origins of setting aside a day in which all citizens can celebrate the harvest and acknowledge what a successful growing year means for all of us. I thought about the bulging grain-bins of my youth, the jars upon jars of meat and peas and pickles ranged on groaning shelves in the cellar. I wondered how people who’ve grown up in our cities, living possibly on the tenth floor of Saskatoon Tower, would relate to the theme of harvest gratitude.

I thought about the endless choice, the seemingly unlimited quantity of food at Costco, Safeway, Sobeys, Bigway. And I wondered, who first had the foresight to know that secure as we may feel at any given time and place, our well-being still depends on the harvests in the plantations, the farms, the vineyards, the gardens and greenhouses and on the labour and sweat of neighbours, and ultimately on the rain, the soil and the sunshine that is so, so easily taken for granted until it fails.

I started with the Old Testament and found that in the NIV, at least, the word “thanksgiving” appears at least a dozen times in different places.

Psalm 95, 1-3: 
Come, let us sing for joy to the Lord;
    let us shout aloud to the Rock of our salvation.
2 Let us come before him with thanksgiving
    and extol him with music and song.
3 For the Lord is the great God,
    the great King above all gods.

The Lord will surely comfort Zion and will look with compassion on all her ruins; he will make her deserts like Eden, her wastelands like the garden of the Lord. Joy and gladness will be found in her, thanksgiving and the sound of singing.

Two things stand out for me in the Old Testament accounts of the Children of Israel as a thankful people.

The first is that communal thanksgiving seems most often to be linked to celebration, and celebration includes singing accompanied by trumpets, cymbals, harps and Lyres. (Celebrating with my body as in dancing, prancing, shouting and praising God spontaneously is not my best thing, in fact it’s not my anything.) 

But singing, ah, singing I can do. I’m a baritone so I can sometimes switch bass to tenor and back again and when we Mennonites conference and hundreds of us are gathered together like early Christians at Pentecost, we can celebrate the goodness of God; the sopranos become our harps, the altos our lyres, the tenors our trumpets and the basses our drums.

The spirit of joy and thankfulness can fill vast arenas with harmonious sound.

Gratitude, thankfulness needs to find expression. Whether it be the simple, verbal “thank you,” the spontaneous embrace, even the Hallmark card, something is needed to seal and communicate gratitude. 

Thanks bottled up inside can leave gaps in relationships; a meal for which God, farmers, gardeners, labourers are not thanked openly and genuinely is a meal undeserved. A meal shared under the knowledge of how great a blessing it really is can become a benediction of thanksgiving.

Leviticus 7:12 & 13
If they offer [gifts] as an expression of thankfulness, then along with this thank offering they are to offer thick loaves made without yeast and with olive oil mixed in, thin loaves made without yeast and brushed with oil, and thick loaves of the finest flour well-kneaded and with oil mixed in.

Along with their fellowship offering of thanksgiving they are to present an offering with thick loaves of bread made with yeast.

An accompaniment to the thanksgiving celebration in ancient times was the offering. In Levitical law, each celebrant was required to bring a “fellowship offering,” of three kinds of “thick bread,” plus an offering of yeast bread.

Sacrificial offerings disappear with the incarnation of Jesus, of course, but we have maintained the principal of the offering, calling the vessel in which we deposit our gift an “offering plate.”

Our prayers over the offering generally ask God to bless the gifts we bring so that his kingdom should grow and prosper, that the hungry should be fed, the naked clothed, the sick and imprisoned be visited and healed.

We don’t burn our offerings or believe that the smoke from such a fire would rise up as incense to God. Neither do we consider our offerings to be the source of our salvation.

But surely, our gratitude for the blessings we enjoy should result in overflowing generosity, and that, I think, would qualify symbolically as sweet incense to God. 

A quote:
The first official Canadian Thanksgiving occurred on April 15, 1872, when the nation was celebrating the Prince of Wales recovery from a serious illness. By the end of the 19th century, Thanksgiving Day was normally celebrated on November 6. However, when World War 1 ended, the Armistice Day holiday was usually held during the same week. in 1957 the Canadian Parliament proclaimed Thanksgiving to be observed on its present date on the second Monday of October to prevent the two holidays from clashing with one another.” (Wikipedia).

There’s something amusing about a statutory, national “thanksgiving day,” as if there’s now declared to be one day of gratitude and 364 days of . . . well, of business as usual. When you hold the door at the post office for someone carrying packages, she doesn’t say “thank you” because its Thanksgiving Day, but because you just now made her life easier with a helpful, courteous gesture. “You’re welcome.” 

We think of the Pilgrims and their connection to a designated Thanksgiving celebration. “The event that Americans commonly call the “First Thanksgiving” was celebrated by the Pilgrims after their first harvest in the New World in October, 1621. This feast lasted three days, and was attended by 90 Native Americans and 53 Pilgrims. The New England colonists were accustomed to regularly celebrating “thanksgivings,” days of prayer thanking God for blessings such as military victory or the end of a drought.” (Wikipedia)

There are similarities between the ancient Hebrew celebrations of Thanksgiving and the American Thanksgiving Day on the fourth Thursday in November and Canada’s Thanksgiving Day on the second Monday of October. There are stark differences as well.

One is that the holiday has become a family event more than a community celebration. Gratitude to God for a year’s blessing, for a bountiful harvest, for a disaster averted or a victory won no longer figures heavily in Thanksgiving Day observances. Much has changed in every aspect of how nations and communities behave since King David wrote the thanksgiving verse that opens Psalm 95.

Although I can hardly see the entire population of Saskatoon, for instance, gathering in one place to sing praise and thanks to God for his goodness, I’m pretty sure that as a church, we could do more to model thankfulness in our world. And why would we do that? 

Here’s one good reason:

Another quote:
In positive psychology research, gratitude is strongly and consistently associated with greater happiness. Gratitude helps people feel more positive emotions, relish good experiences, improve their health, deal with adversity, and build strong relationships.”

It may be a chicken-and-egg thing, but thankful people are happier people, happy people tend to express gratitude more for their good fortune, and all of this connects to mental and physical health, to resolution of conflicts, to well-being, and if anyone ever expressed God’s desire that people be happy and healthy, it was Jesus whose ministry included healing as well as teaching. 

For Christians and Jews, the need to practice thankfulness to God for food, for shelter, for a portion of health and well-being goes without saying. Also, because personal health, healthy relationships, a way out of conflicts all depend in part on the gratitude factor, there’s good reason to preserve what we have and to build on it.

Let me suggest a few scenarios imagining how, for instance, Aberdeen Mennonite, Eigenheim Mennonite, Cornerstone Church, Plains Conservative Mennonite or all of us Anabaptists and all the other communities that share a history of God’s goodness and grace could actively build on our practices of thankfulness.

Imagine it’s 2030. Mennonite Church Saskatchewan has dwindled down to 18 churches, all with static or declining membership. Discouragement and pessimism are running high and there’s talk about selling the Mennonite Youth Farm and Shekinah in order to survive.

But in a bold step, the MC Sask Council rents SaskTel Centre in Saskatoon for a weekend and invites all the people in the province sharing an Anabaptist heritage to gather there, purely for the purpose of celebration, of communal thanksgiving.

Hutterites, Old Colony, Bergthaler, General Conference, Mennonite Brethren, and others are called to a time of feasting, of singing, of story and conversation. Speakers and videos remind everyone there of the faithfulness of leaders of the Radical Reformation of which they all share a legacy.

The history of MCC reminds everyone that service is a shared Anabaptist value; dialogues on being salt and light to a world in conflict abound.

And, oh, the singing. Nun Danket alle Gott; Now thank we all our God.


The story has two possible endings: 1) Only half of the MC SK people and a scattering of MBs and Bergthalers register, the arena and the busses are canceled and penalties levied, and half of the Mennonite Youth Farm property is sold to stave off bankruptcy,

or 2) Church conferences have become tired enough of unnecessary divisions to embrace this unique initiative. Ten thousand nearly fill the arena and can’t get enough of the atmosphere of gratitude and good fellowship and the singing and the laughter around the tables. It’s like they’d stepped for a short time into Psalm 95: “Let us come before him with thanksgiving and extol him with music and song.”

Could it be the beginning of realizing the degree to which we’re the same instead of defining ourselves by how we’re different?

Another imagined scenario: It’s 2019, today maybe. We’ve been to church and listened to a sermon by George Epp (great grandson of our first pastor) on gratitude, on thankfully living life. We go home to a dinner with family and some friends. A nicely browned turkey, mashed potatoes, baby peas, stuffing, a green salad lead us to hurry the prayer so we can get at the feast. 

Someone says, “Anna, would you lead us in Grace?”

It’s not always easy to come up with an impromptu meal grace, even when we’re all together and we’re all happy for the company and the bounty on the table.

To thank God as the provider of the sun and the rain that led up to this day isn’t hard. Our traditional graces do this nicely. “Come Lord Jesus be our guest, and let this food to us be blest, Amen”

But poor Anna, she knows how much time and effort were invested in making the turkey and the potatoes and the peas and the salad possible and to thank God without thanking the people seems to leave something out.

There’s an image of how God’s blessing is delivered on earth that I find enlightening. It goes something like this: “God’s hands are at the ends of my arms, His voice is in my mouth, His kindness and compassion are delivered through my love for my neighbour, my family, my community.”

If this is true, then our gratitude to God is made real in our gratitude for one another.

Anna knows she can’t lead the family in a prayer so long that the mashed potatoes grow cold. But if she could, she might well pray, “Thank you Mary for getting up early to begin preparing this feast, Thanks, Jake, for raising the turkey, thanks migrant Mexican workers for picking the lettuce . . .. Thanks, God, for Mary and Jake and the Mexican migrant workers. Amen

To be grateful to God without being grateful to each other leaves out a part that’s so important in our relationships, that can add so much to our very happiness.

And one last thing. I have a certain preoccupation with roots, with the foundations on which my good fortune, my good faith, my good family, my good community rest.

Do we ever visit the Tiefengrund Cemetery, put our hands on the memorial to Peter Regier and thank God for the work this sacrificing servant did to bind us together into a Saskatchewan Valley community of faith? Have we forgotten our Rosenort legacy?

Do we give thanks for our forefathers and fore-mothers who took such risk to tear themselves from their homes, cross the ocean and re-establish communities here in the land of plenty?

Or are we “just for today” people, who have no interest in our past, in the martyrs who gave their lives to keep the flame of the gospel as expressed in Jesus Christ alive, the many who died securing the separation of church and state so that the kingdom of God could prosper? Do we give thanks for our ancestors, our saints?

To summarize:
  • Thankfulness and its expressions are traditions older than Moses.
  • The expression of gratitude means less if it’s not accompanied by celebration and offering—at least if Old Testament witness is to be our guide.
  • The benefits of thankfulness and the evidence of it in our speech, in our singing, in how we live our daily lives is like a therapy of love, an undeniable health and happiness benefit.
  • The light that thankful, celebratory, generous Christian communities shine on our world is immeasurable.
  • And in our thanks, the saints who went before us should never be forgotten.
Let’s pray: Lord, Creator, God. We are overwhelmed when we think of the goodness poured down on us by your loving hands. Accept our celebration, our offerings, our mindfulness as an expression on this Thanksgiving Sunday. It’s our acknowledgment that all good things come from you, delivered through the hands and voices of your faithful servants. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Amen




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Please hand me that Screwdriver!

Do I dare eat a peach?

A Sunday morning reflection on Sunday mornings